Investing in Interest Rate ETFs in Europe: XEON vs US Bonds
European investors seeking to track short-term interest rates have multiple options, each with different implications for currency exposure and costs. This article compares investing in a euro-denominated ETF like XEON, which tracks the Euro Short-Term Rate (€STR), with investing in US Treasury bond ETFs such as IB01. We will explore the impact of currency risk, the difference between hedged and unhedged versions, and the costs involved, including double conversion fees. A comparative table at the end illustrates how returns vary depending on whether you invest in euros, US dollars without hedging, or US dollars with hedging.
What is XEON and How Does It Work?
XEON (Xtrackers II EUR Overnight Rate Swap UCITS ETF) is a money market ETF that synthetically replicates the €STR rate plus a small spread. It is a low-risk, highly liquid instrument designed for parking cash in euros. Because it is denominated in euros, there is no currency risk for euro-based investors. The total expense ratio (TER) is very low, around 0.10% per year. This makes XEON an efficient way to earn the overnight rate without the hassle of currency conversion or the need to monitor exchange rates.
Investing in US Bonds (e.g., IB01) and Currency Risk
When a European investor buys an ETF like IB01, which tracks short-term US Treasury bonds, the underlying assets are in US dollars. Even if the ETF is listed on a European exchange in euros, the fund must convert euros to dollars to buy the bonds, and later convert back when selling. This introduces currency risk: the final return is the sum of the bond yield plus the change in the EUR/USD exchange rate. If the dollar strengthens against the euro (e.g., from 1.10 to 1.05 EUR/USD), the investor gains from both the yield and the currency appreciation. Conversely, if the dollar weakens (e.g., from 1.10 to 1.15), the currency loss can offset or exceed the interest earned. Thus, unhedged US bond ETFs expose the investor to double conversion costs and significant exchange rate volatility.
Hedged vs Non-Hedged ETFs
To eliminate currency risk, some ETFs offer a hedged version (e.g., IB01 Hedged). The fund manager uses derivative instruments such as forward contracts to neutralize the effect of exchange rate fluctuations. With a hedged ETF, the investor receives the return of the underlying asset as if it were in euros. However, hedging is not free. The main cost is the interest rate differential between the two currencies, known as the carry cost. Typically, US interest rates are higher than eurozone rates, so hedging the dollar exposure costs roughly the difference. This cost reduces the net yield. Therefore, a hedged US bond ETF will likely yield less than the unhedged version if the dollar remains stable, but it protects against adverse currency moves.
Comparison Scenarios: Euro, US Non-Hedged, US Hedged
The following table summarizes the key differences between investing in a euro money market ETF (like XEON), an unhedged US bond ETF (like IB01), and a hedged US bond ETF. We assume a base scenario where US short-term rates are 5% and euro short-term rates are 3%. The exchange rate is 1.10 EUR/USD initially, and we consider three cases: dollar unchanged, dollar strengthens to 1.00, and dollar weakens to 1.20.
| Factor | Euro ETF (XEON) | US Bond Unhedged | US Bond Hedged |
|---|---|---|---|
| Currency risk | None | Full EUR/USD exposure | Neutralized via hedging |
| Source of return | Euro short-term rate (3%) | US short-term rate (5%) + currency change | US short-term rate (5%) minus hedging cost |
| Approximate hedging cost | N/A | N/A | About 2% (rate differential) |
| Return if dollar unchanged (EUR/USD = 1.10) | 3% | 5% | 3% (5% – 2% hedge cost) |
| Return if dollar strengthens (EUR/USD = 1.00, gain 9.1%) | 3% | 5% + 9.1% = 14.1% | 3% (hedge neutralizes currency gain) |
| Return if dollar weakens (EUR/USD = 1.20, loss 8.3%) | 3% | 5% – 8.3% = -3.3% | 3% (hedge protects against loss) |
Conclusion
Choosing between a euro-based ETF like XEON and a US bond ETF depends on your risk appetite and currency outlook. XEON offers simplicity and safety for euro cash holdings with no currency risk. Unhedged US bond ETFs provide an opportunity for higher returns if the dollar appreciates, but carry significant downside risk if the dollar falls. Hedged US bond ETFs give you US interest rate exposure without currency volatility, but at the cost of the interest rate differential. European investors should carefully consider these factors and the double conversion costs before investing. For those who want to avoid currency speculation, a euro-denominated ETF like XEON is the most straightforward choice.
Remember that past performance is not indicative of future results, and exchange rates can be highly volatile. Always consult with a financial advisor to align your investments with your risk profile and financial goals.
Do you want to invest? Do you need ideas or do you want to talk?
Replicate my value-based contrarian portfolio on eToro automatically (minimum €100, with a historical return of +518.34% since 2017) or let's connect directly.